Difference between revisions of "Blisters on a Rudder"

From Westerly-Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(Peeling the Gel Coat)
 
(20 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 14: Line 14:
 
The rudder was damaged at leading edge corner and water was dripping out.
 
The rudder was damaged at leading edge corner and water was dripping out.
  
With the rudder upside down water also came out from around the top edge.
+
With the rudder upside down water also came out from around the shaft on the top edge.
  
 
[[File: Poppedblisters.jpg|400px|]]  
 
[[File: Poppedblisters.jpg|400px|]]  
Line 20: Line 20:
 
Since repairs were obviously going to be required to the bottom of the rudder I decided to investigate the some blisters.
 
Since repairs were obviously going to be required to the bottom of the rudder I decided to investigate the some blisters.
  
The blisters were not what I expected as osmotic blisters seeming to be more like the intact gel coat being forced away from the core over an area of about 12 to 1.5" diameter.  
+
The blisters were not what I expected as osmotic blisters seeming to be more like the intact gel coat being forced away from the core over an area of about 1.0" to 1.5" diameter.  
  
 
This is not obvious in the pictures.
 
This is not obvious in the pictures.
 
After opening up some of the blisters they all were wet inside.
 
After opening up some of the blisters they all were wet inside.
 +
 +
==Drying Out==
  
 
[[File:Drying_out.jpg |400px|]]
 
[[File:Drying_out.jpg |400px|]]
  
The hole along the bottom of the rudder was opened up and the rudder set up in a shed to allow it to dry.
 
  
 +
The hole along the bottom of the rudder was opened up as a groove along the full length of the rudder and the rudder was set up in a shed to allow it to dry.Water continued to drip out through November, December and January but at the beginning of February it was dry enough to pass over to the local fibre glass shop with instructions to repair the bottom and seal the holes up.
 +
 +
 +
The bottom was repaired but when the holes were investigated inside it was found the gel coat was damaged. There were holes possibly as a result of previous attempts to repair osmotic blisters. The holes had been filled but had not been reinforced with glass and the filler was actually soft.
 +
 +
==Peeling the Gel Coat==
  
Water continued to drip out through November, December and January but at the beginning of February it was dry enough to pass over to the local fibre glass shop with instructions to repair the bottom and seal the holes up.
 
  
 +
[[File: Peeled.jpg|600px|]]
  
The bottom was repaired but when the holes were investigated inside it was found the gel coat was damaged. There were holes possibly as a result of previous attempts to repair osmotic blisters. The holes had been filled but had not been reinforced with glass and the filler was actually soft.
+
It was decided that the whole of the rudder needed to be peeled. This was done with an electric planer revealing the laminate underneath to be dry and in good condition.
  
[[File:testy core.jpg|250px|]]
+
Now one thing in common with fibre glass shops is they are not delicate.
 +
 
 +
As can be seen a test core was drilled through the blade and a hole routed out near the shaft to expose the steel underneath.
 +
 +
Inside the Rudder the steel work can be seen to be bright and the welds are in excellent condition. Quality Westerly construction
  
 
[[File: Inside_the_rudder_1.jpg|400px|]]  
 
[[File: Inside_the_rudder_1.jpg|400px|]]  
  
Now one thing about fibre glass repairers is they are not delicate.
+
The rudder was found to be cored with a grey aireated resin which although crumbly had not absorbed water.
 +
It was concluded that the water inside the rudder was between the core and the inside of the gel coat resulting in the large area blisters observed.
  
 
[[File:Close_up_of_inside.jpg |400px|]]
 
[[File:Close_up_of_inside.jpg |400px|]]
  
[[File: Peeled.jpg|400px|]] [
+
The rudder is currently waiting for some bad weather so the fibre glass shop can work on it (as they can't work outside)
  
 
[[File:Test hole refilled.jpg |400px|]]
 
[[File:Test hole refilled.jpg |400px|]]
 +
 +
The test hole has been filled with solid resin and the next step is to recover both sides of the core with laminate (peel ply) gel coat. I am told that will be done by the end  of the week so hope to load a picture soon.
 +
 +
[[File: Reskinned.jpg|600px|]] [[File: Rudder_back.jpg|600px|]]
 +
 +
==Advice if you have blisters in your rudder==
 +
 +
I suppose my advice would be dont despair it is fixable and you wont need a new rudder. If you choose to spot treat your blisters that is probably a good idea but do not just fill the holes. Make sure you do a proper repair and seal up with resin, glass and then gel coat to waterproof the area. Also seal (sikaflex) round the top of the shaft.
 +
 +
The idea of drilling a hole in the bottom of the rudder to drain it is not really going to work as the core is so solid and the water will sit under the gel coat.
 +
This is the second rudder I know of that has been opened up and the steel work found to be in good condition.
 +
 +
Or you can just leave it until like me you have to do something and then have the rudder rebuilt.

Latest revision as of 13:28, 8 December 2022

The Story

I had been aware of blisters in the rudder for some time but chose to ignore them until I damaged the leading edge of the rudder on a sand bank in the middle of the Thames Estuary (Middle Sand). At the same time I was aware of a leak around the rudder tube that required the rudder to be dropped for investigations.

The rudder.jpg

After lift out a hole was dug and the rudder dropped.

Rudder removed.jpg


Leading edge.jpg Top of rudder.jpg

The rudder was damaged at leading edge corner and water was dripping out.

With the rudder upside down water also came out from around the shaft on the top edge.

Poppedblisters.jpg

Since repairs were obviously going to be required to the bottom of the rudder I decided to investigate the some blisters.

The blisters were not what I expected as osmotic blisters seeming to be more like the intact gel coat being forced away from the core over an area of about 1.0" to 1.5" diameter.

This is not obvious in the pictures. After opening up some of the blisters they all were wet inside.

Drying Out

Drying out.jpg


The hole along the bottom of the rudder was opened up as a groove along the full length of the rudder and the rudder was set up in a shed to allow it to dry.Water continued to drip out through November, December and January but at the beginning of February it was dry enough to pass over to the local fibre glass shop with instructions to repair the bottom and seal the holes up.


The bottom was repaired but when the holes were investigated inside it was found the gel coat was damaged. There were holes possibly as a result of previous attempts to repair osmotic blisters. The holes had been filled but had not been reinforced with glass and the filler was actually soft.

Peeling the Gel Coat

Peeled.jpg

It was decided that the whole of the rudder needed to be peeled. This was done with an electric planer revealing the laminate underneath to be dry and in good condition.

Now one thing in common with fibre glass shops is they are not delicate.

As can be seen a test core was drilled through the blade and a hole routed out near the shaft to expose the steel underneath.

Inside the Rudder the steel work can be seen to be bright and the welds are in excellent condition. Quality Westerly construction

Inside the rudder 1.jpg

The rudder was found to be cored with a grey aireated resin which although crumbly had not absorbed water. It was concluded that the water inside the rudder was between the core and the inside of the gel coat resulting in the large area blisters observed.

Close up of inside.jpg

The rudder is currently waiting for some bad weather so the fibre glass shop can work on it (as they can't work outside)

Test hole refilled.jpg

The test hole has been filled with solid resin and the next step is to recover both sides of the core with laminate (peel ply) gel coat. I am told that will be done by the end of the week so hope to load a picture soon.

Reskinned.jpg Rudder back.jpg

Advice if you have blisters in your rudder

I suppose my advice would be dont despair it is fixable and you wont need a new rudder. If you choose to spot treat your blisters that is probably a good idea but do not just fill the holes. Make sure you do a proper repair and seal up with resin, glass and then gel coat to waterproof the area. Also seal (sikaflex) round the top of the shaft.

The idea of drilling a hole in the bottom of the rudder to drain it is not really going to work as the core is so solid and the water will sit under the gel coat. This is the second rudder I know of that has been opened up and the steel work found to be in good condition.

Or you can just leave it until like me you have to do something and then have the rudder rebuilt.